Home > Our Design Lab > Formative Tasks > Evaluate the Possibilities_ED

Evaluate the Possibilities_ED

Description 

How can we choose a solution to the problem?
Select the optimum solution to move the process forward. Look to combine ideas, eliminate those that are unworkable because of constraints, and decide on two or three to flesh out before deciding on a single solution.
 
Common Core Standards Assessed: ELA.SL.1, 4, 6
NGSS Assessed:  HS-ETS1-1, 1-3

 

Time To Complete 

1-3 Hours

I Can Statements 

  • I can evaluate solutions to my engineering challenge by:
    • Identifying an accurate list of criteria and constraints
    • Applying the criteria and constraints systematically
    • Considering the ideas and input of my collaborators
  • I will know if my evaluation of solutions to my engineering design challenge is of high quality if it:
    • Accurately identifies the criteria and constraints
    • Systematically applies the criteria and constraints
    • Considers the ideas and input of my collaborators

Suggestions for Assessing Student Readiness to Move Forward:

  • Confer with students, asking probing questions about their evaluation to gauge how well it meets the quality criteria.
  • Ask students to describe their brainstorming process and the solutions they generated and explain (orally or in writing) how it meets the quality criteria for a high-quality challenge.
  • Ask students to self-evaluate their work after completing one of the activities below.
Possible Activities 
  1. Ask students to brainstorm a list of challenges that the team will have to overcome (budget, time, expertise) to make their product or system a reality. Then use the criteria and constraints to complete a decision-making matrix to weigh the pros and cons of each solution. 

  2. Have students use a multi-vote process to narrow down ideas after brainstorming

Downloadable Resources 
Login to See More